Before I started dating Jos, when we were friends and I had no intention of ever dating him (not ’cause I hated him or anything, but because he was too young, plus already had a girlfriend, plus I wasn’t looking to be someone’s dom, plus I wasn’t sure I could handle his level of dorkiness), he told me that he wanted three things in a girlfriend:
- radical honesty
- sympathetic interpretation
- a dom
Throughout our relationship, Jos has made it really easy for me to be more honest with him than I’ve been with anyone I’ve dated. Just so we’re clear, I don’t think radical honesty is for everyone any more than, say, polyamory is for everyone. I tend to think it’s actually right for hardly anyone. But having a partner who encourages you to be radically honest, and who can actually handle it (thrive on it) when you are, is great.
Too bad Jos doesn’t have a partner like that.
Lately it has been coming out how much undeclared “stuff” Jos has. I mean “stuff” that, in an ideal world, he would have talked to me about and we would have resolved. There are ways we used to do d/s, ways that he encouraged, ways I eventually backed away from, against some resistance from him, that make him angry and fearful to remember. And he has other anger against me, I think, from the poor ways I’ve handled some of his concerns in the past.
Damn. The way I’m writing this feels unfair to myself. The truth is, compared to almost anyone, I am awesome at listening and addressing concerns. Jos has reported, throughout our entire relationship, that he has felt listened to, heard, supported, and taken care of.
At the same time, I kind of suck. I tend to hear things in all-or-nothing terms. (“I don’t really like it when you X” translates immediately in my head to “You shouldn’t ever X again.” This is very hard when it’s a kink activity.) I tend to think things are about me, or about the relationship, when they are just isolated feelings or thoughts. (“I’m disappointed that you never tie me up” => “I’m sad and angry about our disappointing sex life, which I hate.”) I’ll eventually really address your concern (as best I can, which isn’t always that well – it’s hard for people to change very much, honestly), but I’ll freak out first. (By “freak out” I mean cry, become stiff with fear, stop making eye contact, that kind of thing.)
Right now, we’re experiencing a strange dynamic. Jos is opening up to me about this stuff more and more, and he feels more able to do so than ever. (I’ve been making a lot of effort to be calm, listen, remember that not everything is about me, and so on.) So he feels like things are more awesome than ever before. On my side, though, I’m being exposed to a lot of knowledge I didn’t have before about Jos’s pain, anger, frustrations, and experiences with me, so for me, it feels like things are worse.
I don’t want to make it sound like I come home at night and Jos has some laundry list of my sins. It isn’t like that at all. It’ll go more like this.
Him: You’re really listening to me lately. I feel so loved.
Me: Yeah, I’m trying.
Him: I feel like I can’t convey to you how good things are because I’d have to tell you how they were in the past and then…I don’t want to go there.
Me: So, there’s a lot of stuff that you were kind of angry about and you’re realizing it lately.
Him: Yeah, there is. When I think about it.
Me: What kind of stuff?
Him: Dev, there’s really nothing you don’t know about. Just…I think I told you things in the past, but too subtly. I was afraid of what I would do to you, or how you’d respond. You were the best I ever had. And I didn’t even let myself feel some of it.
Me: Scary.
Him: Yeah.
Me: You have to be more honest with me. It’s the only way it can work, if it can work.
Him: I know, just…yeah. I’m working on it.
That is totally not a conversation that actually occurred — more like a pastiche. But it is kind of how the conversations go. We’re talking around the actual “stuff.” (I do know the specifics, for the most part. We just haven’t talked through it with the new understandings.) I want to get into more of it soon, but we just haven’t had the time.
There are a lot of people — relatively secure, happy, low-drama people — who can have complaints or little fears or angers and just let them go. You don’t need to tell your partner every little thing that bugs or scares you. But Jos is particularly bad at letting stuff go, and instead tends to not talk about it (out of very legitimate concerns), but then become angry and afraid because he feels like he can’t talk about it. If you basically suck at suppressing things, and you can’t let shit go, there’s not much choice but to express them, is there?
Of course, any time you say that your partner “can’t let things go” you risk learning that, no, they actually let a huge amount of things go, but what they need to deal with is the tiny remnant. In other words, you’re so much worse than you ever imagined that even the 10% they have to discuss with you is overwhelming. Cheery thought, that :-)
Anyway, I wish I had found a way to write this post with more content and specifics, but this is what we’re dealing with right now. It’s an interesting time.